PDA

View Full Version : Education, Publishing, Etc.


viscousmemories
10-12-2006, 04:15 AM
I've been doing a temp job this week working on 'correlations' for a publishing company (of sorts). Basically, it works like this:

Company A decides that want to market a textbook to American public schools, so they create an outline of their textbook broken down into lesson plans, each of which is broken down into "focus questions". Then they hire Company B (where I'm working) to correlate each of the hundreds of focus questions with the relevant national and/or state educational standard.

So for example, a Language Arts lesson plan might be "American Novels: The Great Gatsby" and the focus question might be "How were the effects of America's new-found wealth in the 1920s expressed in F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby?"

Now, say I'm currently working on the state of Idaho (which I was today). I would go to the sheet of educational standards for Idaho, and find something that at least roughly correlates with the above lesson plan and enter the code in the database. For example, this actual standard:

Idaho Language Arts - ID-752.02.c

Interpret the social, cultural, and historical significance of a text: Ancient Literature; British Literature; American Literature; World Literature.

So, as you can imagine with a few hundred focus questions, upwards of 50 states* and vastly diverse standards (Pennsylvania's Social Studies standards are about 10 times longer than Lousiana's, for example), that's quite a lot of correlations to make.

On the bright side, the correlations for this particular project were already done previously. Unfortunately they were done very badly. Hence a group of folks at the company went through all the states and highlighted the ones that didn't have correlations, had duplicates or really bad correlations, and they brought in a gang of us temps (10 in all - Tue thru Fri) to fix the mistakes.

Anyhoo, the work is pretty monotonous but it's interesting to me on multiple levels. For one thing, learning a little about how things work in the educational publishing industry is interesting. It's also pretty appalling to learn that we have such widely divergent, apparently arbitrary educational standards at the state level. Some of the states (like Pennsylvania) have literally dozens of detailed American political history requirements, and other states have one or two.

It's also interesting how some states' Language Arts standards are much more heavily focused on critical thinking and analysis of non-fiction, and others much more on creativity and appreciation of classic fiction. There are other interesting things, but I'm even boring myself now!

Thank the gods I happen to post on these fora and be reading A People's History of the Supreme Court right now! These correlations would be considerably more difficult for a drop-out like me if not for the fora education I've received. I've only had to use Wikipedia two or three times.

*As funny as it sounds, Iowa has no standards.

Ari
10-12-2006, 05:07 AM
That sounds both interesting and brain numbing... enjoy.

Kyuss Apollo
10-12-2006, 05:25 AM
I have a friend that edits math books for Prentice-Hall in Massachusetts. He's had some interesting stories not too unlike yours VM. If ever I wrap up this MA thesis I'm thinking of getting into a little free-lance editing with Prentice-Hall or some similar text book co--already did an interview with P-H, and got the nod for some free-lance work as soon as I get my degree wrapped up. As much as I enjoy teaching most days, I can't imagine that text book editing is even remotely as stressful as teaching, lol. :overwork:

There can be wide range of standards applied even within a particular state--here in RI some districts are using the national standards, others (like where i work) are using something else, though in social studies we are probably going to switch over to the national standards rather than continue with the ones we are now using that were developed by the local collaborative and currently used by...probably only the district where I work? Yeah. The term is "Standards" is fairly oxymoronic, since states and even individual districts have the power to pick whatever standards they want. In any event, most decent teachers could look at any competently written set of standards for their content area and likely be able to state that that's what they were doing already anyway, before all this attention came down on "standards."

Roland98
10-12-2006, 06:06 PM
*As funny as it sounds, Iowa has no standards.

Our state board of ed doesn't make curriculum decisions like most states do. Everything is essentially left to the districts. This means more work at the level of individual schools, but it's been a bit of a bonus WRT the evolution/ID issues, as the Discovery Institute has no central board to lobby for inclusion of intelligent design--they'd have to take it to every school district.

Anyhoo.

Sounds like an interesting assignment! :)