Thread: News Miscellany
View Single Post
  #49  
Old 01-26-2015, 02:27 PM
Clutch Munny's Avatar
Clutch Munny Clutch Munny is offline
Clutchenheimer
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Canada
Gender: Male
Posts: VMMMLXXXV
Default Re: News Miscellany

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kael View Post
[ If that little bundle of cells barely starting to differentiate is a human life, the state has the same prima facie obligation to protect that life as it does for any other.
I think this is the most that could follow, but presumably something akin to personhood would also be needed; "human life" broadly applies to a shed skin cell, too, and doesn't mean much to the state on its own. But even if we read "person" for "human life" -- a huge allowance -- the p.f. protection from the state is widely seen as defeated in precisely cases like pregnancy, for reasons argued most vividly and famously by Judith Jarvis Thomson: the state's mandate to look out for the well-being of an adult citizen does not plausibly extend to compelling me to remain hooked up to that citizen by tubes for 9 months, not even if it would kill that citizen for me to disconnect the tubes.
__________________
Your very presence is making me itchy.
Reply With Quote
Thanks, from:
Crumb (01-26-2015), Kael (01-26-2015), LadyShea (01-26-2015), The Man (02-02-2015)
 
Page generated in 0.07585 seconds with 11 queries