Battlestar Galactica Mafia - Game Thread

[Smilin]

Originally Posted by beyelzu

Smilin following you around in votes is pretty damn suspicious as well

Following me ANYWHERE would be a mistake, my friend.....in this make-believe game or in life.....

Following me will only result in:
1. Getting your ass lost
2. Getting your ass arrested/pulled over/searched/ticketed
3. Getting your ass canned at work....

[JamesBannon]

you do realize there is a "copy" of you using the same exact avatar here don't yah?

Actually, I think suds had before me which would me a copy of suds.

[Ensign Steve]

Originally Posted by Crumb

Good point, ZA.

Here are the folks who haven't voted yet:
Brinkenjon
Ensign Steve
The Tick
Sun Tzu
Cappuccino

So this is my initial suspect list.

unvote; vote: Brinkenjon

I'll vote this evening. Then y'all can have all day tomorrow to figure out what it all means!

[Smilin]

Originally Posted by Crumb

Good point, ZA.

Here are the folks who haven't voted yet:
Brinkenjon
Ensign Steve
The Tick
Sun Tzu
Cappuccino

So this is my initial suspect list.

unvote; vote: Brinkenjon

Indeed....

Unvote
Vote Sun Tzu

Non-participators/lurkers are no. 1 toaster suspects...

@ ES

[Ensign Steve]

Originally Posted by JamesBannon

Actually, I think suds had before me which would me a copy of suds.

I think that's the point. Aren't the Cylons the copies?

[Smilin]

Originally Posted by Ensign Steve

I think that's the point. Aren't the Cylons the copies?

yep....the "improved" versions are human copies...

And all the female "versions" are all hawt...

ES is female...

ES is hawt...

hmmmmmmmmmm.............

[Ensign Steve]

My character is hot, too, but it ain't a cylon.

Then again, most people on TV are hot, so that's not really saying much.

[cappuccino]

I don't have much. The quiet ones are my suspects so far, that's something to start with.

The only one that is really picking at my brain is Smilin. Smilin because he seems to be making a lot of noise and flashy posts. Is he trying to distract us or is he just being his usual glamorous self?

I'm curious to see how Joshua Adams turn out, his posts are rather adamesque and The Tick was adamesque too and he turned out to be scum. It seems like everytime somebody is adamesque, they turn out to be scum. But that's probably my cognitive bias talking.

[Ensign Steve]

[beyelzu]

Originally Posted by cappuccino

I don't have much. The quiet ones are my suspects so far, that's something to start with.

The only one that is really picking at my brain is Smilin. Smilin because he seems to be making a lot of noise and flashy posts. Is he trying to distract us or is he just being his usual glamorous self?

I'm curious to see how Joshua Adams turn out, his posts are rather adamesque and The Tick was adamesque too and he turned out to be scum. It seems like everytime somebody is adamesque, they turn out to be scum. But that's probably my cognitive bias talking.

Indeed, if someone isnt going to be active, we have to vote them off.

It is probably a little early yet, but lynch the silent ones is something that pretty much has to be done.

[Smilin]

Originally Posted by cappuccino

The only one that is really picking at my brain is Smilin. Smilin because he seems to be making a lot of noise and flashy posts. Is he trying to distract us or is he just being his usual glamorous self?

I do tend to make a lot of noise at everything I do...

Me...glamorous?

You've actually made my day Capp...

and don't worry...my carrying on and noise rattling is getting ready to grind to a minimum...

I actually got give a job task today....

[cappuccino]

cool

yeah bey, the quiet ones are frustrating, if they signed up to play the game, then show up dammit. I know I sometimes get carried away with work and don't come back till hours later but still...

I have to get back to work but I'll come back in the evening and try to make an informed vote.

[wei yau]

Great point about the timed game being an advantage, ES.

We still have a day, so we can afford to bide our time for a little while longer. Usually, I'm not a proponent of airlocking the quiet ones, but given that lurking is a good Cylon tactic in this timed game, I can see the merits.

Still, we've got little to go on...

I'm keeping my vote on Smilin...for now. Yeah, he posts a lot and it's either (a) his usual self or (b) an act to mimic his "usual self" to avoid suspicion. Maybe he's changed his first day behavior, but in my first game with him, he usually went pretty hard after someone, pretty early.

He did this with lot of attempts to encourage others to vote his way.

He's not doing that now, so either his gameplay has evolved or his attempts to mimic the manic ways of "Smilin" is focusing too heavily on the "mania" and less on the lynch-mob.

[Smilin]

Originally Posted by wei yau

...

I'm keeping my vote on Smilin...for now. Yeah, he posts a lot and it's either (a) his usual self or (b) an act to mimic his "usual self" to avoid suspicion.

(c) bored at work with very little to do and enjoy carrying on with the people here I've come to know as friends.

Just check my posting history and you'll see I've been just as active and "manic" in MANY other threads today, yesterday, and the day before.....

The people here amuse me....and that's a bad thing? It's either this or actually have to STUDY for my professional engineering license....

oh yeah...add procrastinator to your list of "Smilin" facts.....

Maybe he's changed his first day behavior, but in my first game with him, he usually went pretty hard after someone, pretty early.

my strategy has been different in each game....

He did this with lot of attempts to encourage others to vote his way.

Yes. And I always wound up lynched as a result of that, now didn't I? With the exception of one game where that fucker crumb threw me under the bus, I've always turned up "town" too....

You forgot that point, now didn't you?

That's why in the last game I FULLY expected to get lynched after making my case against Nightson....

He's not doing that now, so either his gameplay has evolved or his attempts to mimic the manic ways of "Smilin" is focusing too heavily on the "mania" and less on the lynch-mob.

Actually, this is a quiet, useful diversion for me in life, like spending time with my boys and playing WoW is for me.

That's it in a nutshell, Wei. I'm here to distract myself while at work.....nothing more.

[Sun Tzu]

vote Smilin

All the noise with little substance seems like scum trying to hide in the crowd.

[Sun Tzu]

Why is someone invisible?

[Crumb]

Normally I think that would make sense, but this is really normal Smilin behavior. I don't think it is very telling.

[Smilin]

The lurker emerges....

Unvote

Now it's simply a matter of who else is just lurking/not participating

[Sun Tzu]

Ok, well not babbling about toast etc. is how I play.

[Crumb]

Anti-toast babbling is a scum tell!

[Smilin]

Originally Posted by Crumb

Normally I think that would make sense, but this is really normal Smilin behavior. I don't think it is very telling.

Yes, I'm going through a manic phase if ya'll can't tell. That's the up side...the down side is when the depression will eventually set it....

OOOOHHHHH...LET'S LYNCH SMILIN' JUST CUZ HE'S POSTING SOO DAMMM much....

Makes about as much sense as Mick carrying on about VM, or that the wrath of god is about to strike us all because of all the lesbians, or the Liv isn't a real person initially made up by VM.....



gimme a break!

[beyelzu]

4 invisible people right now.

Ive got my eye on you bastards, sort of.

[JamesBannon]

Originally Posted by Sun Tzu

Why is someone invisible?

Probably because they're allowed to be in this game.

[Smilin]

Originally Posted by Sun Tzu

Why is someone invisible?

Because I've busted scum in two seperate games watching for PM activity after nightfall was declared...YAYYYYY ME!

and everyone is apparantly paranoid at this point....

The first time it happened was with Adam (our GM) and Wei yau (one of my accusors)

Noone would listen, they both turned up scum, and I was lynched....

What little fact that wei DIDN'T point out to you is that in every single game I have almost always carried on like this and with the EXCEPTION of one game in which I was scum with Crumb, I have always turned up town.....

So....trying to lynch me for being "too talkative" is a definate scum tell in my play experience....

[Smilin]

Originally Posted by beyelzu

4 invisible people right now.

Ive got my eye on you bastards, sort of.

Those x-ray glasses that let you either detect invisible people or see through peoples clothing advertised in comic books are just a cheap gimmick....yah know?