A Nancy Drew Mafia Mystery - Page 4

Gonzo · #76 02-15-2011, 03:35 AM

Woops, I meant, unvote; vote Adam. :wave:

Neat tactic. That took you about 3 seconds of consideration.

Deadlokd · #77 02-15-2011, 03:38 AM

Why did you switch to Adam when you were initially suspicious of lyrical? Why not stay on her?

Gonzo · #78 02-15-2011, 03:43 AM

Because Adam's jumping in to call me out on revenge voting is more suspicious. Anyone who would ignore her bullshit argument to pile up for the sake of a lousey "OMG he OMGUS'd" vote looks to has ill intentions. Certainly not pro-town ones. Tell me what is pro-town about voting somebody for revenge voting?

His only motive was to add pressure and look for a flail. I think he's using Day One scum tactics and it's painfully obvious.

ravenscape · #79 02-15-2011, 03:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lyrical

LOL coming from someone who questioned my agreeability yet I was town and you were scum...

The last time I questioned your agreeability I was scum.

Adam · #80 02-15-2011, 03:45 AM

Have you played with me before? I always pressure for flail on day one. [Thanks] for flailing.

Deadlokd · #81 02-15-2011, 03:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gonzo

Because Adam's jumping in to call me out on revenge voting is more suspicious. Anyone who would ignore her bullshit argument to pile up for the sake of a lousey "OMG he OMGUS'd" vote looks to has ill intentions. Certainly not pro-town ones. Tell me what is pro-town about voting somebody for revenge voting?

His only motive was to add pressure and look for a flail. I think he's using Day One scum tactics and it's painfully obvious.

Scum revenge vote all the time. Especially on shaky premises.

Gonzo · #82 02-15-2011, 03:50 AM

Yes and what exactly about that helps the town?

Also, do you think it is fair to judge someone's gameplay off of another game that is still underway?

Gonzo · #83 02-15-2011, 03:51 AM

@ Adam

Deadlokd · #84 02-15-2011, 03:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gonzo

Yes and what exactly about that helps the town?

Well that's the point isn't it? Scum aren't helping town.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gonzo

Also, do you think it is fair to judge someone's gameplay off of another game that is still underway?

On day one anything goes. But without a definite conclusion as to your role in the other game (is there one? Have you died?) any meta is pointless. IME meta usually goes "you were scum in that ABC game and you're playing that way in this game. Therefore you're probably scum."

But if you haven't cardflipped on the other game then meta is useless and lyrical is pulling crap out of a hat. And Adam is following her.

Demimonde · #85 02-15-2011, 03:56 AM

Lol, lyrical didn't make an argument, she had a meta vibe. Your argument otoh G is bullshit. There are plenty of town motivations for pressuring you given the reaction you made.

FOS Gonzo.

DL, I can understand the joke vote. I can somewhat understand the surprise at crossposts. But why the "oh shi-" unvote reaction? It seems to me that you were afraid of appearing heavy handed. Scum are the ones worried about appearances. I am still uneasy about your reaction.

Never the less, unvote, vote Gonzo because that seems the wisest place for my vote at present.

Gonzo · #86 02-15-2011, 03:56 AM

Quote:

Scum revenge vote all the time. Especially on shaky premises.

Nevertheless (whether I would agree with that or not) my vote against lyrical had more rational reasoning than hers against me. The same for my vote against Adam and more so.

lyrical vote for my for useless meta
I voted for her because she voted for me unfairly

adem voted for me making an accusation of revenge voting
I voted for him because that's a scum tactic

He hadn't even given me time to defend myself against lyrical before jumping on the bandwagon. Either he's scum or he's so used to being scum that his town game has turned anti-town.

Gonzo · #87 02-15-2011, 03:58 AM

Ha! Scum coming out of the woodwerk now. They think they found their first prey. :giggle:

It's adorable.

Gonzo · #88 02-15-2011, 03:58 AM

Quick, clown defend yourself against four people at once!

Demimonde · #89 02-15-2011, 04:00 AM

How do you reckon that voting for someone who OMGUS's is a "scum tactic?"

Gonzo · #90 02-15-2011, 04:01 AM

[quote=Deadlokd;912076]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gonzo

Yes and what exactly about that helps the town?

Well that's the point isn't it? Scum aren't helping town.[quote]

That wasn't directed at you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gonzo

Also, do you think it is fair to judge someone's gameplay off of another game that is still underway?

On day one anything goes. But without a definite conclusion as to your role in the other game (is there one? Have you died?) any meta is pointless. IME meta usually goes "you were scum in that ABC game and you're playing that way in this game. Therefore you're probably scum."

But if you haven't cardflipped on the other game then meta is useless and lyrical is pulling crap out of a hat. And Adam is following her.

Neither was that.

Gonzo · #91 02-15-2011, 04:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Demimonde

Lol, lyrical didn't make an argument, she had a meta vibe. Your argument otoh G is bullshit. There are plenty of town motivations for pressuring you given the reaction you made.

FOS Gonzo.

DL, I can understand the joke vote. I can somewhat understand the surprise at crossposts. But why the "oh shi-" unvote reaction? It seems to me that you were afraid of appearing heavy handed. Scum are the ones worried about appearances. I am still uneasy about your reaction.

Never the less, unvote, vote Gonzo because that seems the wisest place for my vote at present.

Wow look an FOS and a vote all in on post!

It isn't wise at all. It's suspicious.

You are taking advantage of the fact a lot has happened in a short time and are adding pressure while ignoring my reasoning for voting.

Quote:

How do you reckon that voting for someone who OMGUS's is a "scum tactic?"

It's a way to put a townie on the defensive. Adam is overlooking lyrical's use of meta and going after me for responding to her unfair reasoning. He wasn't interested in anything more than getting me to flail. Just look at his first response to me. It's anti-town.

Deadlokd · #92 02-15-2011, 04:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Demimonde

Lol, lyrical didn't make an argument, she had a meta vibe. Your argument otoh G is bullshit. There are plenty of town motivations for pressuring you given the reaction you made.

FOS Gonzo.

DL, I can understand the joke vote. I can somewhat understand the surprise at crossposts. But why the "oh shi-" unvote reaction? It seems to me that you were afraid of appearing heavy handed. Scum are the ones worried about appearances. I am still uneasy about your reaction.

Never the less, unvote, vote Gonzo because that seems the wisest place for my vote at present.

Not heavy handed. I just don't want to park a vote on a growing bandwagon, especially since, at the time, Gonzo was just being Gonzo. Now though...

[quote=Gonzo;912082][quote=Deadlokd;912076]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gonzo

Yes and what exactly about that helps the town?

Well that's the point isn't it? Scum aren't helping town.

Quote:

That wasn't directed at you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gonzo

Also, do you think it is fair to judge someone's gameplay off of another game that is still underway?

On day one anything goes. But without a definite conclusion as to your role in the other game (is there one? Have you died?) any meta is pointless. IME meta usually goes "you were scum in that ABC game and you're playing that way in this game. Therefore you're probably scum."

But if you haven't cardflipped on the other game then meta is useless and lyrical is pulling crap out of a hat. And Adam is following her.

Neither was that.

Does that render my questions and comments useless then? You're flailing a lot G, why is that?

Deadlokd · #93 02-15-2011, 04:12 AM

Damn, forgot to fix the quote tags.

Gonzo · #94 02-15-2011, 04:12 AM

Now who wants to be honest and admit that using meta from a game currently underway has no place in this new game?

Gonzo · #95 02-15-2011, 04:14 AM

Quote:

You're flailing a lot G, why is that?

I am calling people out on their bullshit. I'm perfectly calm. Calling my arguments 'flail' is just another way to dismiss a person.

I really don't care what your answers are to questions directed at Adam. I want him to answer me.

Gonzo · #96 02-15-2011, 04:15 AM

Hey, DL,

.

Deadlokd · #97 02-15-2011, 04:18 AM

ZOMG! 2:11pm here. :lol:

ravenscape · #98 02-15-2011, 04:18 AM

Ok, this shit looks pretty odd.

livius drusus · #99 02-15-2011, 04:19 AM

Player	Votes	Voters
Adam	1	Gonzo
beyelzu	1	fragment
Crumb	0
Dagon	0
Deadlokd	1	Crumb
Demimonde	0
Elouise	0
Flint	0
Flying Monkey	1	slimshady2357
fragment	0
Gonzo	5	mickthinks, LadyShea, lyrical, Adam, Demimonde
JEROME DA GNOME	0
Kael	0
LadyShea	1	wei yau
Leesifer	2	Pan Narrans, Dagon
lyrical	0
mickthinks	0
Pan Narrans	0
ravenscape	0
slimshady2357	0
teasasue	0
wei yau	0

12 votes needed for a lynch.

Deadlokd · #**100** 02-15-2011, 04:20 AM

On one hand calling someone on meta for a game that is still being played is odd. No, it's weird and wrong. You didn't answer G, are you dead in that game yet? Have you card flipped? But Gonzo's flail is big.