The Resistance 2 - Game Thread

[Kael]

Love the histrionics, JEROME. I wonder if I could get you to wager anything meaningful on whether I am a spy...

[Daphne Girl]

I am thinking about proposing either
Daphne, Adam, Jerome or
Daphne, Adam, Contra
what about Chunks, Jerome and myself?

[Daphne Girl]

I would like to make a proposal we all like. I will wait a little while to see if you guys have any ideas. If I don't hear back soon, I will just make my proposal.

[Daphne Girl]

Didn't hear from anyone, so I will make my proposal.
Daphne, Adam, Jerome.

[Crumb]

Proposal 4.4: Daphne, Adam, Jerome

Everyone please PM your vote in. Daphne, Adam and Jerome please include either SUCCEED or FAIL for this mission along with your vote.

[Crumb]

Adam and Contra, we need your votes!

[Adam]

PM sent. I voted No. Half of each of my suspected spy pairs is on the proposal, so if it goes through, it will fail and we'll learn nothing. I'm interested to see what Kael proposes.

[Contrapposto]

If we pass the proposal, do we get ANOTHER 5 consecutive vote downs before loss, Crumb?

[Crumb]

Oops sorry Adam, missed your PM somehow.

If we pass the proposal, do we get ANOTHER 5 consecutive vote downs before loss, Crumb?

Correct. That's why we are numbering them 4.1, 4.2, etc. the X.5 proposal is always the must pass proposal.

[Contrapposto]

That's an important detail to clarify first.

[Contrapposto]

Originally Posted by Crumb

Oops sorry Adam, missed your PM somehow.

Correct. That's why we are numbering them 4.1, 4.2, etc. the X.5 proposal is always the must pass proposal.

x-post....thanks, Crumb.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Crumb

Oops sorry Adam, missed your PM somehow.

Oh, no, I just sent it when I posted that.

[Crumb]

Proposal 4.4 is rejected by the voters 3-3.

Proposal	Proposed By	Adam	Daphne	Kael	chunks	Jerome	Contra	Mission Result
1.1: Adam, Daphne	Adam	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	SUCCESS
2.1: Chunk, Jerome, Contra	Daphne	No	Yes	No	No	No	No	n/a
2.2: Adam, Daphne, Kael	Kael	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	FAIL
3.1: Adam, Daphne, chunksmediocrites, Contra	chunks	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	SUCCESS
4.1: Adam, Daphne, Contra	Jerome	Yes	No	No	No	Yes	No	n/a
4.2: Daphne, Jerome, Contra	Contra	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	n/a
4.3: chunks, Contra, Daphne	Adam	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	n/a
4.4: Daphne, Adam, Jerome	Daphne	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	n/a

The do or die proposal 4.5 will be made by the new leader Kael.

#	Player
1	Adam
2	Daphne
3	Kael	LEADER
4	chunks
5	Jerome
6	Contra

[chunksmediocrites]

So Kael, you voted no on
4.1: Adam, Daphne, Contra
4.2: Daphne, Jerome, Contra
4.3: chunks, Contra, Daphne
4.4: Daphne, Adam, Jerome.

The mission that had a fail vote was Adam, Daphne, Kael; I'm assuming you don't want to run that mission again.

That leaves the possibles of
Adam, Daphne, chunks
Daphne, Jerome, chunks
Jerome, chunks, Contra
chunks, Contra, Adam
Kael, Daphne, chunks
Kael, Daphne, Jerome
Kael, Daphne, Contra
Kael, Jerome, chunks
Kael, Jerome, Adam
Kael, Jerome, Contra
Kael, Contra, Adam
Kael, Contra, chunks
Kael, Adam, chunks

Did I miss some combos? Anyway, I'm going to vote for whatever mission you propose.

[Contrapposto]

Umm...we kinda have no choice if we want to win.

[Daphne Girl]

Originally Posted by Contrapposto

Umm...we kinda have no choice if we want to win.

lol. very true.

[Daphne Girl]

Kael, I was just wondering when you plan on making your proposal? I have a busy few days ahead.

[Kael]

Originally Posted by chunksmediocrites

So Kael, you voted no on
4.1: Adam, Daphne, Contra
4.2: Daphne, Jerome, Contra
4.3: chunks, Contra, Daphne
4.4: Daphne, Adam, Jerome.

You'll notice all of those include Daphne, my current frontrunner between her and Adam for the spy.

I have to hope I'm right, since if my proposed mission fails I'll look even more like a spy than I already do, and our next mission is another four-man. That means every non-spy must be sent or we lose, and if I look too much like a spy to send, it's Game Over.

I propose:
Kael, Adam, Chunks.

Based on the assumption that Daphne is a spy, and that the only two proposals she voted 'NO' on included her and Contra, which she wouldn't want if Contra is the other spy.

Here's hoping...

[Crumb]

Proposal 4.5: Kael, Adam, Chunks

Please get your votes in. Kael, Adam, and Chunks please also send your SUCCESS or FAIL in with your vote.

[Crumb]

Proposal 4.5 is passed!

show spoiler

And mission 4 is a success!

Proposal	Proposed By	Adam	Daphne	Kael	chunks	Jerome	Contra	Mission Result
1.1: Adam, Daphne	Adam	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	SUCCESS
2.1: Chunk, Jerome, Contra	Daphne	No	Yes	No	No	No	No	n/a
2.2: Adam, Daphne, Kael	Kael	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	FAIL
3.1: Adam, Daphne, chunksmediocrites, Contra	chunks	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	SUCCESS
4.1: Adam, Daphne, Contra	Jerome	Yes	No	No	No	Yes	No	n/a
4.2: Daphne, Jerome, Contra	Contra	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	n/a
4.3: chunks, Contra, Daphne	Adam	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	n/a
4.4: Daphne, Adam, Jerome	Daphne	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	n/a
4.5: Kael, Adam, Chunks	Kael	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes		SUCCESS

Mission	Result	Votes	Players
1	SUCCESS	2S	Adam, Daphne
2	FAILED	2S, 1F	Adam, Daphne, Kael
3	SUCCESS	4S	Adam, Daphne, chunksmediocrites, Contra
4	SUCCESS	3S	Kael, Adam, Chunks
5

Congratulations to The Resistance team! You win 3-1!

Your spies were Contrapasto and Daphne.

[Kael]

Boom, headshot!

[Contrapposto]

Great job, Kael.

[Contrapposto]

Well, Daphne. It looks like we were thinking the same thing on mission three in choosing to "succeed" the mission while hoping the other of us failed.

I wished I had voted "yes" on proposal 4.4. I just didn't think it was going to get the votes and didn't want to look incriminating.

[Jerome]

Originally Posted by Crumb

Your spies were Contrapasto and Daphne.
[/spoiler]

[Jerome]

Originally Posted by Kael

Boom, headshot!

I owe you something.