Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
Quote:
Originally Posted by LadyShea
peacegirl, I have continually asked for you to explain how you think light works when there is no observer. If I understand what light and objects are doing in your model- when there is nobody seeing or photographing the interactions- then I can better formulate pertinent questions to the model of seeing you are proposing.
As it is your ideas require light and matter to interact in inconsistent and unpredictable ways. With this being the case, nothing you say about sight can possibly make any sense or possibly be true.
|
Hold it right there. Where is this model unpredictable or inconsistent? |
In your model "things like mirrors" reflect, what things? Why? How? If I hand you an object can you predict whether it reflects or absorbs? If I describe the properties of a material down to it's chemical composition, but don't let you see the object, can you predict what color will be revealed when you do see it?
What happens to specific light that is not absorbed?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by peacegirl
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by LadyShea
SO, can you, or can you not tell me how light and matter interacts without involving people or cameras?
|
Of course I can. It reacts the same way whether we're seeing it or taking a picture of the object or not. I will say once again that this is not magic. |
The same way as what?
Okay, then are you willing to work with me on my desert/rock/plant but no people example? It's a few pages back