[Spacemonkey]

Originally Posted by Spacemonkey

You did say the photons will be on Earth. The retina is on Earth, and you've said there will be photons at that retina on Earth instantly at 12:00 when the Sun is first ignited. I asked where they came from, and you said they were previously located at the surface of the Sun. Is there some part of this that you wish to change or retract?

If not, then please answer my question: You say that in Lessans' newly ignited Sun example there will be photons at the retina on Earth at the very moment (12:00) that the Sun is first ignited, and that these photons came from and were previously located at the surface of the Sun. So when could they have been located at the Sun? (Pick an answer and we can see if it works)

a) Before 11:52.
b) At 11:52.
c) Between 11:52 and 12:00
d) At 12:00
e) Sometime after 12:00

Bump.