Quote:
Originally Posted by wstewart
Quote:
Originally Posted by davidm
Actually, Wayne, I have answered the question...
|
That's a demonstrably untrue statement, and it should raise eyebrows among those who are considering the question.
Review your posts and state the truth of the matter. Else you'll tie yourself willfully to a demonstrably untrue statement. |
Well, Wayne, if you think it's demonstrably untrue, then you're entitled to your opinion. Let's suppose,
arguendo, that it's demonstrably untrue that I gave an answer at the Dawkins board. I now propose to answer you here. Fair enough? I've nothing against you and genuinely enjoyed our conversation/jousting, however you prefer to characterize it.
So I will answer any question that you have here. I propose that we start afresh. In the meantime, did you see my taxonomy of claims about what happens after we die? Can you fill in the blank for existential passage/generic subjective continuity? I would prefer you do it so there is no misunderstanding. I also would like you to take a look at Lessans' writings on this subject, if peacegirl would be so good as to share them with you, and let me know what you think of them vis-a-vis exisential passage.