Quote:
Originally Posted by thedoc
Useing Wstwart's example... Who gets this 'germinal substance'...?
|
Essay reasoning is not as you suggest.
In this thread I've isolated the essay's preparatory scenario of
Old and New Paul, with reason. E.g., it's easy to see that no 'germinal substance' is posited in that scenario.
What is posited?
And in your view, is anything more required, in order to justify the essay's conclusion that Old Paul passes to New?