Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
Quote:
Originally Posted by LadyShea
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by peacegirl
You haven't proven me wrong;
|
I don't have to prove you wrong, the burden of proof is on you, as the one making the positive claim. |
LadyShea, I have shown you where you are wrong with your idea of what constitutes a modal fallacy. |
No you haven't. You keep saying you have, but can never give me the link to this alleged demonstration. I have requested you offer a refutation a dozen times, and your response has never gone beyond the assertion that "it isn't an example of the modal fallacy". That's not showing anything, you know.
So, once again, if you think you have posted a decent refutation, go find it and give me the link or post number.
Quote:
|
You have cotton in your ears, yet you are influencing people in here who don't know enough about fallacious reasoning to know who to believe.
|
Huh? Who do you think I am influencing? Which participant in the thread, besides you, do you think knows less about fallacious reasoning than I do, and is sitting here confused?
Quote:
|
That means people here are going to accept your analysis and conclude that Lessans is wrong, when I know Lessans is not wrong.
|
What on Earth makes you think anyone is going to blindly accept my analysis?
Quote:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by peacegirl
you have only added further proof that your opinions are just that: opinions.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by LadyShea
My opinions are opinions! Yes, that is a true statement. Tautological, but true.
|
Then hold onto that thought before spouting off your opinion which means nothing in terms of what is true.
|
LOL, what are you raving about? This is quite a stupid thing to say. All I can offer in any discussion is my opinions, same as you. Same as anyone.