Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
Quote:
Originally Posted by LadyShea
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by peacegirl
A camera uses the same exact light as the eyes, therefore the light is at the film in the same way the light is at the retina. I already explained this.
|
You never explained how light is "at" the retina or camera film without requiring light to have different properties and follow different laws than are known, so this is just a faith based assertion on your part. Repeating it doesn't make it an explanation. You also keep going back to "the brain" which doesn't apply to cameras.
The problems you need to solve, in a nutshell:
1. If a brain is required for efferent vision to work, as Lessans claimed, then it can't work for cameras. If cameras can work the same way, then no brain is required at all, contrary to Lessans statements.
2. If you insist that light is located somewhere, you must explain how it is there and where it came from. |
Oh my goodness LadyShea, why can't you get this? A brain does not have to be involved with cameras. The knowledge regarding the brain and eyes (if it turns out to be true, which I believe it will) helps us to understand cameras and why the photograph always turns out to be exactly the same as what someone is seeing in real time. The lens of the camera is within the field of view of the object, just like the eyes. It's no different yet you are imagining us here on Earth waiting for light to arrive. That's why you are right back to asking me the same old question, "how it is there and where did it come from?" |
I can't "get" what you refuse to meaningfully
explain.
If light is on the surface of camera film,
regardless of how we see, it has to be there by some mechanism and had to have come from somewhere.
Lessans discussion of the brain and eyes doesn't help us understand anything at all about cameras or light.
Quote:
|
It's no different yet you are imagining us here on Earth waiting for light to arrive
|
Yes, because a camera
cannot utilize light that is not on Earth, specifically on the camera film or sensor