Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
Nooooooo, you are failing to understand the efferent model, so how in the world are these two opposing [theories] ever going to intersect. I don't care how many times you say this, you are still expressing the afferent position which requires the light to travel and reach earth. Nothing has changed.
|
You don't understand the efferent model either. And you still haven't told me what your mysterious third option is.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
Nope, not at all, not when you come from the opposite position which does not change the properties of light...
|
You are changing the properties of light whenever you say the light at the film or retina can be there without having traveled there and without having been emitted there.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
Right, due to the requirements necessary. These requirements, if looked at carefully, do not change any properties of light whatsoever but you can't wrap your head around it because you cannot understand why photons do not have to reach Earth first.
|
Your requirements do not explain how the light got from the Sun to the film. There is a very real 92 million mile distance between these two locations. If the photons get from the one location to the other, then they must either pass through the intervening space (i.e. travel), or
not pass through the intervening space (i.e. teleport).
Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
I am not even going to repeat myself for the hundredth time.
|
Good. Instead of repeating weaseling evasions, try actually answering honestly for once.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
No, but people do.
|
Then try speaking of the fields of view of people, instead of mindless nonsense about the fields of view of objects.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
You just don't see the validity because of your inability to understand the efferent model.
|
No-one can understand what you refuse to explain. You don't understand it either.
Quote:
Originally Posted by peacegirl
There IS no photon problem; that's just it.
|
Denial will not make it go away. The photon problem is that you need photons at the film on Earth at the very same moment the Sun 92 million miles away first starts emitting them, and you have absolutely no explanation for how this can be achieved.