[peacegirl]

Originally Posted by davidm

On the contrary, you stupid moron, I understand fully what he is arguing in Chapter 10. It's you who doesn't understand it. The "you" to which he refers, of course, is not a personal "you," but what Tom Clark at naturalism.org calls "generic subjective continuity" and what Wayne Stewart calls "existential passage." I already helpfully explained to you that what Lessans is proposing is identical to what Clark and Stewart propose, and if you sent Chapter 10 of Daddy Dumb Ass's book to them, you would have two allies, at least on this one subject.

But you won't do that because you really don't know what your father is talking about in Chapter 10, and hence are unable to see that it is identical to what Clark and Stewart propose. You don't understand it, but you support it, only because he wrote it.

There is no subjective continuity David. There is NO continuity with a person who once lived. There is no existential passage as if to say the person who died goes through a tunnel and ends up a different person. This is pure science fiction. I know you love your sci-fi but this is getting way out of hand. You are the moron David, and you're all puffed up with the belief that you know better than Lessans by offering a valid refutation. You're not. You are an arrogant asshole.