[Gonzo]

Originally Posted by fragment

You know that still leaves plenty we could talk about, like who votes to lynch for who and whether their reasons for it are solid. FWIW I think talking about the leadership vote was good when we had nothing else to talk about, but we've moved well past that and have plenty of other stuff to discuss. Like who do you think is most suspicious so far, Deadlokd?

I am really unsure that this is a good way to look at this game. I don't know how much you have played before, but in mafia the only reason to ignore the elephant in the room is that you are hiding something. I have nothing to hide here and it is my interest to find out what is going on as well as eliminate all threats.


I am also in the crowd bothered by Bros hobbit-speech but understand it brings some color and fun to serious LotR bizness. Otherwise, even if I have some trouble reading his style, he has been participating, projecting ideas, and has not said anything which should garner special attention to me. Still, I'm watching him.

I also agree that liv and Nightson were too aggressive in their canidacies for mayor, but the matter is said and done now. I am not terribly displeased with the haste of it, but I hope we made the right choice in Dem. She seems to be a good figure head at least. I like that her vote for herself came late. Others were not so modest.

Major suspicion on Nightson for his dismissals of conversation. More dictorial than majorial. vote Nightson

Liv is sort of righteous in her ideas even if she is almost always right, and that could be dangerous. I was so positive last game that a townie (slim) was scum and was totally wrong in my assessment. Only did I find out upon his lynching how much time I wasted on assumptions. She is acting hypocritical towards Nightson when she can call him bossy but then say to Kael:

So much for your keeping your mouth shut.

Though I see no cause for alarm as of yet, I will say I find her combative attitude to be counter productive to the town. I am happy to have her as a pouty townie/ powerless scum, than what could have been Mayor Marie Antoinette.

CP I'm glad you have spoke up. You have some ideas that provoke otherwise unmentioned points of view. Even if some of them are newbish and out of ignorance, you seem to be less likely to attack a person without a reasonable explanation.

And it wasn't until I read this:

each statement from another must be analyzed as both the full truth and as a lie

That I saw what appeals to me most in your gameplay. If you can stay true to that idea in this game, you will be very valuable to the town.

Kael I see at his usual place in the town. He has trouble communicating his defense and usually falls victim to circumstance. The only difference is that in this game, I am not leading the war agianst him and see no real reason for making controversy over his every word. He's barely been given the chance to speak his mind.

fragment, bey, slim - I would like to hear from off the top of my head.