The Resistance - Game Thread

[Adam]

I'm trying to figure out if it's more likely that both of you are spies or only one.

I'm inclined to say either send Kael and SR71, or one of them (I have a better feeling about Kael) and me.

[Gonzo]

Anyone against Adam's proposal?

[SR71]

Yep. I favor sending you and Jerome again rather than muddy the water more. If it fails then we can focus on interrogation.

[Gonzo]

Let's try SR71's proposal. Resend me and Jerry. All in favor?

[Kael]

Is that an official proposal, or are you fishing for a phantom vote before you put it up for realz?

[Jerome]

Gonzo, Jerome, and Adam are Failed players.

SR71, and Kael are untested.

I suggest a play which tests the untested. How do we balance the tested with the untested at this point, we have only had two plays, three left, I am open for suggestions.

[SR71]

You and Gonzo passed mission one! Why not just go with that again? This way if it fails we only have a two way psy ops game to play. If one is a spy, I doubt they would let the mission succeed.

[Jerome]

I am up for me again, a known quantity, to myself, the math is easier to work when a factor is known.

[Gonzo]

Yeah that's an official proposal. Jerome and Gonzo.

[Adam]

OK, sending my PM now.

For the record, I'm voting no, since I know that at least one of them is a spy.

[Crumb]

Thanks for the quick votes. I am still waiting on 2 of them.

Proposal 3.1: Jerome and Gonzo

[Crumb]

The results are in. The proposal has passed.

Proposal	Adam	SR71	Kael	Gonzo	Jerome	Mission Result
1.1 - JEROME and Gonzo	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Success
2.1 - Adam, Kael and Gonzo	No			No	No	n/a
2.2 - JEROME, Gonzo, and Adam	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	FAILURE
3.1 - Jerome and Gonzo	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Pending

Jerome and Gonzo you are on mission 3: Please PM me SUCCESS or FAIL for mission 3.

[Crumb]

Mission 3 has failed. If another mission fails the spies will win the game.

Mission	Result	Votes	Players
1	Success	2S	Gonzo, Jerome
2	FAILED	2S, 1F	JEROME, Gonzo, and Adam
3	FAILED	1S, 1F	Gonzo, Jerome
4
5

Mission 4 requires 3 operatives. Jerome is the first leader.

#	Player	Mission 2
1	Adam
2	SR71
3	Kael
4	Gonzo
5	Jerome	*Leader*

[Jerome]

Proposal 4.1: Jerome, Adam, and Kael

I know it's not me, it is unlikely Gonzo and Adam are both Spies, therefore Adam is not a Spy, and I am still sus of SR71 due to his first day 'misspeak'. I really wish we would have sorted him earlier.

[Kael]

Yeah, and Gonzo's gonna say "I know it ain't me!" too... Let me tell you how much weight that proclamation carries...

[SR71]

Yeah, we know for sure one of those two is bad news. Kael, Adam, do you see anything that points to one over the other? Maybe they're both turned? I don't think so, because it's split, 1 pass, 1 fail. If they played by the rules, no extra threadal communication, they wouldn't have risked not failing that mission.

[Crumb]

Originally Posted by JEROME DA GNOME

Proposal 4.1: Jerome, Adam, and Kael

Go ahead and PM your votes in. Feel free to continue discussing as well.

[Gonzo]

Jerome is scum.

[Jerome]

Originally Posted by Gonzo

Jerome is scum.

Well of course that would be your response, what do you think of Adam?

[SR71]

We need yo look at this some more. I know for sure I'm not a spy. I'm holding my vote until we discuss some more.

[Adam]

If I were making a proposal, it would be me, Kael, and one of the two of you. I'm just not sure if I'm more comfortable sending you or Gonzo.

[SR71]

I'm comfortable with Kael. For sure I'm not the bad guy. It's the other three I'm worried about.

[Crumb]

I'm not getting many votes...

[Adam]

I don't want to vote until I hear some more discussion.

I'm particularly interested in Kael and SR's opinions on Gonzo v JEROME.

[Kael]

Honestly I'm in more of a "hang 'em both" position. I don't think it likely that both are spies, but I don't see any compelling reason to pick one over the other as the main suspect. Given that, I'm not really comfortable sending either of them.