LotR Mafia - Game Thread

[beyelzu]

Originally Posted by fragment

What are the chances that Kael is actually a Nazgul and this is a weird gambit? I have trouble seeing what he could be trying to achieve with that, though.

I believe him but I have thought he was a traitor for awhile, he could be lying hoping that we let him live because of the victory condition thing I outlined in my last post. He could have made up his claim thinking that some of us, such as myself, would push to let him live. He also set this up somewhat with his, "what good would it do to lynch me if I am a traitor" post.

[slimshady2357]

So far I'm 2 for 2 on reads. Demi isn't Nazgul and Crumb was Nazgul.

I don't see any reason to doubt my read last night. Sure, it could be wrong. But even then we're lynching the traitor, not a bad thing.

If we don't lynch Kael, then who do we lynch? I'm sure as hell looking at Gonzo right now. Wtf Gonzo? I've given 2 good reads, got a scum lynched out of one of them and you're willing to vote for me because Kael says he is Saruman? That looks scummy as hell.

[slimshady2357]

Oh, I also meant to say that not one of you bastards has said a thing about Nightson dying.

[fragment]

Originally Posted by slimshady2357

Oh, I also meant to say that not one of you bastards has said a thing about Nightson dying.

What's there to say? It has the look of a vig kill, but speculating about that doesn't seem particularly helpful to town unless we're going to massclaim, an idea which I'm still not especially keen on.

[slimshady2357]

Originally Posted by fragment

What's there to say? It has the look of a vig kill, but speculating about that doesn't seem particularly helpful to town unless we're going to massclaim, an idea which I'm still not especially keen on.

We're too far into the game to be worried about revealing info with speculation and/or a mass claim. If some of the numbers you were throwing out there are correct we're damn close to being not able to win.

And the scum have more info than us already.

However, I don't think we should be doing anything until Demi gets back. She may have some very important info for us. It's getting to the point that we need to know what she did with the ring on Night 2 and possibly even last night. We're slowly narrowing down the possibilities of who is who and her info could swing us to the point of being able to win.

unvote

I don't want someone (scum) to hammer early. Kael at L-2 now.

[fragment]

Originally Posted by slimshady2357

We're too far into the game to be worried about revealing info with speculation and/or a mass claim.

I still disagree. How many hobbits there still are and who they are is crucial information that the nazgul don't have. At this point, they don't know if they're better off taking you out or trying to take out a hobbit. At the very least we have a good lynch lined up for today and should leave risking giving away too much info for the next day.

[slimshady2357]

Originally Posted by fragment

At the very least we have a good lynch lined up for today and should leave risking giving away too much info for the next day.

I can agree with that.

Still hoping our mayor will be back soon to at least see what has happened and give her opinions.

[beyelzu]

Originally Posted by slimshady2357

So far I'm 2 for 2 on reads. Demi isn't Nazgul and Crumb was Nazgul.

I don't see any reason to doubt my read last night. Sure, it could be wrong. But even then we're lynching the traitor, not a bad thing.

If we don't lynch Kael, then who do we lynch? I'm sure as hell looking at Gonzo right now. Wtf Gonzo? I've given 2 good reads, got a scum lynched out of one of them and you're willing to vote for me because Kael says he is Saruman? That looks scummy as hell.

That is true, there is zero reason to vote for you unless we believe that it was a scum play yesterday with crumb, and I just don't see that as a scum dance.